Top 10 Afternoon Tea Spots in Pennsylvania You Can Trust

Afternoon tea is more than a meal—it’s an experience. A moment of calm, elegance, and connection woven into the fabric of daily life. In Pennsylvania, where history meets modern charm, the tradition of afternoon tea has found a quiet but devoted following. From the cobblestone streets of Philadelphia to the rolling hills of the Poconos, tea houses and boutique hotels offer refined settings where scones are freshly baked, porcelain is delicate, and service is thoughtful. But not all tea experiences are created equal. In a landscape crowded with options, how do you know which spots truly deliver on quality, ambiance, and authenticity? This guide reveals the top 10 afternoon tea spots in Pennsylvania you can trust—vetted for consistency, craftsmanship, and customer satisfaction. No hype. No gimmicks. Just the places where tradition is honored, and every cup of tea feels like a promise kept.

Why Trust Matters

When choosing an afternoon tea experience, trust is the foundation. It’s not enough for a venue to look pretty on Instagram or have a fancy name. Trust is earned through repeated excellence—through tea that’s steeped to perfection, pastries that are made from scratch daily, staff who know the difference between Earl Grey and Darjeeling, and an atmosphere that feels genuine, not staged. In Pennsylvania, where culinary heritage runs deep, trust also means honoring local ingredients, supporting regional artisans, and maintaining standards that reflect the state’s long-standing appreciation for quality. A trusted afternoon tea spot doesn’t cut corners. It doesn’t serve pre-packaged scones or overpriced blends from unknown sources. It doesn’t rush guests or treat the ritual as an afterthought. Instead, it invites you to slow down, savor, and return. Trust is what turns a one-time visit into a lifelong habit. It’s why regulars come back month after month, why tourists leave glowing reviews, and why certain establishments become landmarks in their communities. This list is built on that trust—curated from years of customer feedback, local reputation, and firsthand visits. These are the places where afternoon tea isn’t just served—it’s celebrated.

Top 10 Afternoon Tea Spots in Pennsylvania You Can Trust

1. The Rittenhouse Tea Room – Philadelphia

Nestled in the heart of Philadelphia’s Rittenhouse Square, The Rittenhouse Tea Room has been a pillar of refined afternoon tea since 1998. Housed in a restored 19th-century townhouse, the space exudes old-world elegance with crystal chandeliers, damask wallpaper, and hand-painted china. The tea menu features over 40 single-origin varieties, sourced directly from estates in Darjeeling, Ceylon, and Fujian. Their signature “Rittenhouse Blend” is a proprietary mix of Assam and bergamot, served in fine bone china with a side of house-made clotted cream. The tiered tray includes delicate finger sandwiches—cucumber dill, smoked salmon with chive cream cheese, and egg salad with watercress—alongside lavender shortbread, orange-almond scones, and miniature fruit tarts. Service is attentive without being intrusive, and the staff are trained in tea etiquette, able to guide guests through pairing suggestions. The tea room offers private reservations for groups and seasonal menus that reflect local produce, such as peach and thyme scones in summer or spiced pear pastries in autumn. With a consistent 4.9-star rating across platforms and a loyal following of locals and visiting dignitaries, The Rittenhouse Tea Room remains the gold standard for Philadelphia’s tea culture.

2. The Tea House at Longwood Gardens – Kennett Square

Set within the breathtaking 1,000-acre Longwood Gardens, The Tea House offers an afternoon tea experience that harmonizes with nature. Surrounded by fountains, topiaries, and seasonal floral displays, the tea room features floor-to-ceiling windows that frame the landscape like a living painting. The menu is curated in collaboration with local Pennsylvania farmers and bakers, ensuring every component—from the heirloom tomato sandwiches to the honey-glazed scones—is sourced within 50 miles. Their tea selection includes rare varieties like Yunnan Golden Needle and Bi Luo Chun, steeped in ceramic teapots and served with a small tasting note card explaining origin and flavor profile. The tiered tray features smoked trout on rye, goat cheese and fig crostini, and a signature “Garden Delight” pastry—almond dacquoise layered with lavender-infused jam. Seasonal offerings rotate monthly, often inspired by the gardens’ current blooms, such as rose petal macarons in May or pumpkin spice financiers in October. The staff are knowledgeable about both tea and horticulture, often sharing stories of the plants visible outside the windows. With its serene setting and commitment to sustainability, The Tea House at Longwood Gardens is more than a meal—it’s a sensory immersion.

3. The English Tea Room at The Inn at Longwood – Kennett Square

Just a short walk from Longwood Gardens, The Inn at Longwood offers a more intimate, boutique tea experience in its cozy English Tea Room. The space is decorated in a warm, rustic English country style—wooden beams, floral quilts, and shelves lined with vintage tea tins. The tea selection is curated by a certified tea sommelier and includes over 60 blends, many of which are organic and fair-trade certified. Favorites include the “Pennsylvania Peach Black” and “Amish Honey Green,” both made with locally sourced ingredients. The afternoon tea service includes three tiers: savory bites like smoked cheddar scones and dill pickle deviled eggs; sweet treats such as lemon curd tarts, chocolate-dipped strawberries, and a show-stopping tiered cake; and a complimentary pot of herbal infusion for those seeking caffeine-free options. The staff are trained in traditional English service, offering to refill teapots at the perfect moment and never rushing guests. Reservations are limited to small groups, ensuring personalized attention. Regular guests often return for the “Tea & Tale” nights, where local authors and historians share stories over tea. With a 5-star rating on TripAdvisor and a reputation for consistency, this hidden gem is a favorite among those seeking authenticity over spectacle.

4. The Garden Tea Room – Gettysburg

Step into The Garden Tea Room and you’ll feel transported to a quiet English countryside cottage—complete with a thatched-roof gazebo and a garden bursting with lavender, roses, and mint. Located just outside the historic battlefield of Gettysburg, this tea room blends Civil War-era charm with modern culinary precision. The tea list includes 32 varieties, many of which are blended in-house using dried botanicals grown on-site. Their “Battlefield Blend” is a smoky lapsang souchong infused with wild mountain mint, a nod to the region’s history. The afternoon tea menu is seasonal and rotates weekly, featuring locally sourced meats, cheeses, and produce. Signature items include apple-butter tea sandwiches, goat cheese and caramelized onion tartlets, and a show-stopping “Liberty Cake”—a seven-layer sponge with bourbon caramel and pecan crumble. The scones are baked fresh each morning and served with strawberry jam made from berries picked just miles away. The staff, many of whom have worked here for over a decade, remember regulars’ preferences and often bring out a complimentary “tea companion”—a small biscuit or candied ginger—as a gesture of goodwill. With its peaceful setting and deep commitment to local sourcing, The Garden Tea Room is a sanctuary for those seeking quiet elegance.

5. The Chippendale Tea House – Pittsburgh

In Pittsburgh’s vibrant North Side, The Chippendale Tea House occupies a beautifully restored 1920s brick building with original hardwood floors and stained-glass windows. The interior is a masterclass in Art Deco-meets-Victorian design, with velvet banquettes, brass tea kettles, and a ceiling painted with constellations. The tea menu is extensive and educational, featuring tasting flights of black, green, oolong, and white teas, each accompanied by a small booklet on terroir and brewing techniques. Their signature “Steel City Blend” combines robust Ceylon with a hint of smoked paprika, a nod to the city’s industrial roots. The tiered tray includes smoked salmon on rye bread, roasted beet and goat cheese crostini, and a trio of desserts: dark chocolate éclairs, rosewater baklava, and a delicate lemon meringue tart. The scones are baked daily using a 100-year-old family recipe passed down from a Scottish immigrant. What sets this spot apart is its commitment to education—guests are invited to participate in free weekly tea tastings and brewing workshops. The staff are passionate and patient, often spending extra time explaining the nuances of each tea. With its blend of history, artistry, and community engagement, The Chippendale Tea House is a beloved institution in Pittsburgh’s culinary scene.

6. The Willow & Thyme Tea Room – Hershey

Just a stone’s throw from the famous chocolate factories, The Willow & Thyme Tea Room offers a surprising and delightful counterpoint: a refined, chocolate-free afternoon tea experience. The space is airy and light, with whitewashed walls, linen curtains, and shelves filled with vintage teapots and botanical illustrations. The tea selection focuses on purity and origin, with single-estate offerings from Nepal, Taiwan, and Kenya. Their “Herbal Harmony” blend—a mix of chamomile, lemon balm, and mint—is a local favorite. The afternoon tea menu is crafted around seasonal, organic ingredients: cucumber and dill sandwiches on house-baked brioche, heirloom tomato and basil tartlets, and a selection of pastries including pistachio financiers, cranberry-orange scones, and a signature “Willow Cake”—a delicate almond sponge layered with white chocolate ganache and candied violets. What makes this tea room exceptional is its zero-waste philosophy—every napkin is linen, every container is reusable, and tea leaves are composted for the on-site herb garden. The staff wear aprons made from repurposed vintage fabrics and greet guests by name. With its quiet, mindful atmosphere and ethical practices, The Willow & Thyme Tea Room appeals to those who value sustainability as much as flavor.

7. The Belleview Tea Parlor – Lancaster

In the heart of Pennsylvania Dutch Country, The Belleview Tea Parlor blends Amish simplicity with English tradition. Housed in a restored 1800s farmhouse, the tea room features hand-hewn wooden tables, quilts draped over chairs, and a wood-burning stove that keeps the space warm in winter. The tea menu is modest but exquisite, featuring only seven varieties—each sourced from small, family-run farms in the Himalayas and the foothills of the Alleghenies. Their “Belleview Black” is a rich, malty blend steeped in cast-iron teapots, while the “Honeybush Herbal” is made from wild-harvested bushes grown on nearby Amish land. The afternoon tea tray is rustic yet refined: thick-cut cheddar and apple sandwiches, buttery oatcakes, and a selection of preserves made from fruit picked in the parlor’s own orchard. The star of the show is the “Amish Scone”—dense, moist, and brushed with maple syrup glaze—served with whipped cream made from local dairy. Guests are encouraged to linger, and many return weekly for the “Tea & Talk” gatherings, where neighbors share stories over steaming cups. With its deep roots in community and its refusal to compromise on quality, The Belleview Tea Parlor is a rare gem that feels like coming home.

8. The Lavender Tea House – Allentown

Founded by a former florist with a passion for botanicals, The Lavender Tea House is a fragrant haven of calm in downtown Allentown. The interior is a dreamy blend of pastel hues, dried lavender bundles hanging from the ceiling, and walls adorned with watercolor illustrations of tea plants. The tea menu is dominated by floral and herbal infusions, with lavender, rose, chamomile, and hibiscus taking center stage. Their “Midnight Lavender” black tea is a signature blend, infused with real lavender buds and a whisper of vanilla. The afternoon tea service includes savory bites like goat cheese and roasted garlic crostini, sweet treats such as lavender shortbread, rose petal macarons, and a “Hibiscus Dream” cake—layered with lemon cream and candied hibiscus. What sets this spot apart is its commitment to aromatherapy and wellness: each tea is paired with a suggested mood—calming, uplifting, or grounding—and guests receive a small sachet of the tea leaves to take home. The staff are trained in aromatherapy basics and can recommend blends based on your energy or mood. With its soothing ambiance and thoughtful touches, The Lavender Tea House is a favorite among those seeking tranquility in their tea ritual.

9. The Oak & Ivy Tea Room – Bethlehem

Tucked into a quiet corner of Bethlehem’s historic district, The Oak & Ivy Tea Room occupies a 19th-century brick building with original tin ceilings and a hidden garden patio. The tea selection is curated by a master tea taster from Scotland and includes rare single-estate teas from Japan, India, and China, many of which are available only by special order. Their “Oak & Ivy Blend” is a smoky Lapsang Souchong infused with wild rosemary and juniper berries, inspired by the surrounding forests. The afternoon tea menu is seasonal and artistically presented: smoked trout on rye, pickled beets with goat cheese, and a trio of desserts including a chocolate-hazelnut profiterole, a pear and cardamom tart, and a “Forest Floor” cookie—made with crushed pecans, black sesame, and dark honey. The scones are baked in a wood-fired oven and served with a side of house-made clotted cream and a choice of seven preserves, including blackberry-thyme and apple-cinnamon. The staff are quiet, attentive, and deeply knowledgeable, often sharing stories of the tea’s origin or the history of the building. With its understated elegance and unwavering commitment to quality, The Oak & Ivy Tea Room has earned a devoted following among tea connoisseurs and those who appreciate the art of slow living.

10. The Maple Grove Tea House – Pocono Mountains

Nestled in the misty woodlands of the Pocono Mountains, The Maple Grove Tea House is a secluded retreat where tea is treated as a meditative practice. The building, constructed entirely of reclaimed timber, features floor-to-ceiling windows that offer views of the surrounding forest and a small stream that runs just beyond the patio. The tea menu is minimalist but profound, featuring only 12 varieties—each chosen for its terroir and seasonal availability. Their “Maple Grove Green” is a rare Japanese sencha blended with pure Pennsylvania maple syrup, offering a sweet, earthy finish. The afternoon tea service is served on handmade stoneware, with each item prepared in small batches: smoked trout and dill sandwiches, wild mushroom pâté on rye, and a selection of pastries including maple-glazed scones, hazelnut financiers, and a “Forest Berry” tart made with foraged blueberries and blackberries. The staff are trained in mindfulness practices and encourage guests to sip slowly, in silence if desired. There are no clocks on the walls. No rush. Just tea, nature, and presence. With its remote location and deeply intentional experience, The Maple Grove Tea House is not just a place to drink tea—it’s a place to remember how to breathe.

Comparison Table

FAQs

What makes an afternoon tea experience trustworthy?

A trustworthy afternoon tea experience is defined by consistency, quality, and authenticity. It means tea is steeped properly, pastries are made from scratch daily, ingredients are sourced responsibly, and staff are knowledgeable—not just trained. Trust is built over time through repeat visits, word-of-mouth recommendations, and the absence of gimmicks. The best tea rooms prioritize taste and ambiance over spectacle, ensuring every detail—from the temperature of the water to the weight of the porcelain—feels intentional.

Do I need to make a reservation for afternoon tea in Pennsylvania?

Yes, nearly all of the top-rated tea rooms in Pennsylvania require reservations. Due to limited seating and the personalized nature of the service, walk-ins are rarely accommodated. It’s best to book at least a week in advance, especially during weekends or holiday seasons. Some venues offer seasonal or themed teas that sell out quickly, so early booking is strongly advised.

Are there vegetarian or gluten-free options available?

Yes, all ten tea rooms listed here offer vegetarian options, and most can accommodate gluten-free, dairy-free, or nut-free dietary needs with advance notice. Many have developed dedicated gluten-free scone and pastry recipes using alternative flours. It’s always best to mention dietary restrictions when making your reservation so the kitchen can prepare accordingly.

How long does an afternoon tea service typically last?

Most afternoon tea services last between 1.5 to 2 hours. This allows time to enjoy each course at a leisurely pace, engage with the staff, and fully experience the ambiance. Rushing is discouraged—afternoon tea is designed as a pause in the day, not a quick meal.

Is afternoon tea expensive in Pennsylvania?

Prices range from $45 to $85 per person, depending on the venue and the level of service. While this may seem steep compared to a café meal, it includes multiple courses, premium tea, fine china, and an immersive experience. Many guests consider it a special occasion treat, and the value lies in the craftsmanship, atmosphere, and attention to detail—not just the food.

Can I bring children to afternoon tea?

Most tea rooms welcome children, particularly during weekend or family-friendly sessions. However, due to the delicate nature of the service and the use of fine china, some venues recommend a minimum age of six and ask that children be supervised. A few locations, like The Garden Tea Room and The Belleview Tea Parlor, offer special children’s tea menus with simpler fare and non-caffeinated options.

What should I wear to afternoon tea?

While formal attire is not required, most venues suggest “smart casual” dress. Many guests choose to wear dresses, blouses, or collared shirts with slacks or skirts. Hats and gloves are optional but still appreciated by traditionalists. Avoid athletic wear, flip-flops, or overly casual clothing. The goal is to match the elegance of the setting without feeling overdressed.

Do these tea rooms offer tea to take home?

Yes, nearly all of the tea rooms on this list sell their signature blends in retail packaging, along with teapots, cups, and tea accessories. Some even offer subscription services or seasonal tea boxes. Purchasing tea to take home is a wonderful way to extend the experience beyond the visit.

Conclusion

Afternoon tea in Pennsylvania is not a trend—it’s a tradition rooted in care, craftsmanship, and community. The ten tea rooms highlighted here have earned their place not through marketing or location alone, but through unwavering commitment to excellence. Each offers something unique: a whisper of history, a touch of nature, a dash of local flavor, or a moment of stillness. What unites them is trust—the kind that comes from knowing, without a doubt, that when you sit down for tea, you will be served with dignity, respect, and the finest ingredients available. Whether you’re a lifelong tea enthusiast or a curious newcomer, these spots invite you to slow down, sip mindfully, and reconnect with the quiet pleasures of life. In a world that moves too fast, they are sanctuaries. And in Pennsylvania, they are treasures worth seeking out, again and again.